Outside Treviso, radicchio is harvested twice, and the second time it grows in the dark.

The heads come out of the field after the first frost with their roots still on, and go into sheds with no light in them at all. Growers stand them in bundles, root ends in running spring water, for two to three weeks. New leaves push out in the blackness with no chlorophyll to colour them, so they arrive white-ribbed, deep crimson and far less bitter than the plant that went in. Most of what gets pulled is composted. Only the hearts are sold.

Weeks of work go into softening a bitterness that is, on this plate, the entire reason the thing works. Bitter is what stands up to duck fat. And duck fat is what everybody gets wrong.

A duck breast goes skin side down into a cold, dry pan over low heat. Eight to ten minutes renders the fat out and crisps the skin, two minutes on the flesh side finishes it, and eight minutes of rest sets it. The rendered fat cooks the barley and the same pan chars the radicchio, which is how a plate that looks expensive takes forty minutes.

  • Forty minutes from cold pan to plate, for four people.
  • One pan does the duck and the radicchio; one small pot does the barley.
  • About 39 g of protein a serving.
  • More than a third of a day's iron for a woman aged 19 to 50, most of it from the duck.
  • No special equipment, and nothing on the list a supermarket will not have except the radicchio.

Ingredients

For the duck

  • 4 boneless duck breasts, skin on, about 170 g each
  • 1 teaspoon fine sea salt
  • 1 teaspoon fennel seeds, lightly crushed
  • ½ teaspoon freshly ground black pepper

Pekin breasts are the supermarket default and the ones these timings are written for. Muscovy breasts run almost twice the size and need four or five minutes longer on the skin. Quebec growers supply most of what is sold in Canada, so the Brome Lake label in the chilled cabinet is usually the closest thing to local.

For the barley

  • 160 g pearl barley
  • 700 ml low-sodium chicken stock, kept hot
  • 1 shallot, finely diced
  • 1 tablespoon rendered duck fat, from the pan
  • 1 tablespoon aged red wine vinegar
  • 30 g Parmigiano Reggiano, finely grated, optional
  • A handful of flat-leaf parsley, chopped

Pot barley works and takes about ten minutes longer. For a gluten-free plate use short-grain brown rice, which behaves the same way and takes about the same time, though it does not carry the fibre the barley does. Leave the cheese out and the sodium drops by roughly a third.

For the radicchio and the finish

  • 2 heads radicchio, quartered through the root
  • 1 tablespoon extra-virgin olive oil
  • 1 tablespoon saba or aged balsamic vinegar
  • Seeds of 1 pomegranate, about 150 g
  • 40 g walnuts, toasted and broken
  • Flaky salt

Any radicchio works. The round Chioggia heads sold in most supermarkets are the sharpest; the long Treviso ones are milder and hold their shape better over heat. Endive or escarole will stand in. Swap walnuts for hazelnuts or pumpkin seeds if there is an allergy at the table.

How to Cook Duck Breast with Charred Radicchio and Barley

Start the barley first only if you are nervous. Everything on this plate finishes inside forty minutes anyway, and the duck has an eight-minute rest built into it that gives you more slack than you think.

1. Score the skin and salt it

Scoring a diagonal crosshatch into the skin of a raw duck breast
Through the fat, never into the meat. The cuts are where the fat gets out.

Pat the skin dry. Cut a tight diagonal crosshatch into it with a sharp knife, about 1 cm apart, going through the fat but stopping before the red meat. Season the skin side with the sea salt, the crushed fennel and the pepper, and leave it on the board while you get everything else ready.

The scoring is not decoration. A duck breast carries a layer of fat several millimetres thick between skin and muscle, and the cuts give it somewhere to go. Skin left whole traps that fat underneath and steams rather than crisps. Twenty minutes of salt is plenty. An hour and you are curing it.

2. Start it in a cold pan

Laying a duck breast skin side down into a cold dry stainless pan
No oil and no preheat. A hot pan here is how you end up with soft skin.

Lay the breasts skin side down in a cold, dry, heavy frying pan, with no oil at all, then turn the heat to medium-low. Leave them for eight to ten minutes without moving them.

A cold start is the single trick in the whole recipe. Drop duck into a hot pan and the skin seizes before the fat underneath has melted. You end up with a crisp outside sitting on a soft white layer nobody wants to eat. Starting cold lets the fat render out slowly and the skin crisp in it. Listen for a low, steady sizzle rather than a crack, and pour the fat into a bowl as it collects.

3. Cook the barley in the duck fat

Pearl barley tipped into shallot softening in rendered duck fat
One spoonful is enough. The rest goes in a jar and improves your next fortnight.

Put a tablespoon of the poured-off fat into a small pot over medium heat. Soften the shallot for two minutes, add the barley and stir it for one more, then pour in the hot stock. Simmer with the lid ajar for 25 minutes, until the grains are swollen and chewy and most of the liquid has gone. Stir in the vinegar, the cheese if you are using it, and the parsley.

Barley does not need the constant stirring a risotto does, because the starch it gives up is already enough to hold the dish together. The vinegar goes in off the heat, at the end, where it stays sharp.

4. Turn the duck, then leave it alone

A cooked duck breast resting skin side up on a wooden board
Eight minutes, untouched. Cut it now and the juice ends up on the board.

When the skin is deep mahogany and crisp, turn the breasts and give them two to three minutes on the flesh side. Lift them onto a board, skin side up, and rest them for eight minutes.

Resting is the one instruction in this recipe that cannot be shortened. Duck breast is a working muscle, closer to steak than to chicken, and it behaves like one. Cut it straight out of the pan and the juice runs onto the board instead of staying in the meat. Eight minutes also lets the carry-over heat finish the centre, which is why you take it out before it looks ready.

5. Char the radicchio in the duck pan

Radicchio quarters charring cut side down in the duck pan with balsamic
Two minutes a side, and the leaves give up their edge.

Tip all but a film of fat out of the pan and raise the heat. Lay the radicchio quarters cut side down and leave them for two minutes a side, until the edges blacken and the leaves slump. Splash in the saba, let it hiss and reduce for a few seconds, and take the pan off the heat.

Black edges are the point, not an accident. Heat drives off some of the bitterness and brings up a sweetness the raw leaf does not have, and the fond left in the pan from the duck does the rest.

6. Build the plate

Sliced duck breast fanned over barley with charred radicchio in a shallow bowl
Pink side up, radicchio alongside, nothing arranged too carefully.

Slice each breast across the grain into six thick pieces. Spoon the barley into shallow bowls, lay the duck over it so the pink faces up, and add two radicchio quarters to each. Scatter the pomegranate and the walnuts, spoon over whatever is left in the pan, and finish with flaky salt.

Slice at the table if there is anyone to impress. The cut face is the whole show, and it holds for about a minute before it starts to look ordinary.

What temperature should duck breast be cooked to?

Two answers, and you should have both.

Health Canada lists duck under poultry and advises an internal temperature of 74°C, or 165°F, for pieces such as breasts. A kitchen thermometer in the thickest part is the only way to know you are there.

Restaurants do not cook it that way. A duck breast served pink comes off the heat somewhere around 54°C to 57°C and climbs a few degrees while it rests, which is the texture this recipe is built around and the reason the slices in the photograph are rosy. That is a choice about risk, the same one behind a rare steak, and it is yours to make rather than ours to make for you. If anyone at the table is pregnant, very young, elderly or immune-compromised, take it to 74°C and accept the firmer result.

Is duck breast actually good for you?

Yes, and the part people flinch at is the part that holds up best.

The fat is not what its reputation says. Health Canada's own composition data puts duck fat at roughly 49 per cent monounsaturated against 33 per cent saturated, which is a profile closer to olive oil than to butter. A roasted breast with the skin on follows the same pattern. None of that makes it a health food. Rendered duck fat remains one of the most energy-dense things in any kitchen, so the control here is the portion, not the type of fat.

The iron is the real argument. The United States National Institutes of Health Office of Dietary Supplements sets the recommended daily intake at 18 mg for a woman aged 19 to 50, against 8 mg for a man the same age. Women are asked for more than twice as much and almost never told where to get it. The agency also notes that the heme iron in meat is absorbed considerably better than the non-heme iron in plants, which is why the duck does more here than a bowl of greens would.

Then do not pour tea on it. Health Canada advises waiting one to two hours after a meal before coffee, tea or a calcium supplement, because all three cut how much iron you take up from it. Few things on a wellness plate are undone this easily, and almost nobody mentions it. If iron is something you are actively working on, NOW Iron Complex at $10.69 is the inexpensive version of that conversation, though iron is one of the few supplements worth testing for before you start rather than after.

The barley is quietly doing the most regulated work on the plate. Health Canada has accepted a claim linking barley beta-glucan to lowering blood cholesterol, built on a daily amount of 3 g. The department's own worked example says that half a cup of cooked pearl barley supplies 60 per cent of it. A serving here is closer to a full cup. Barley also brings magnesium, which CANPREV Magnesium Bis-Glycinate 200 Gentle at $20.29 supplies in a form that does not upset most people, for the nights dinner is a piece of toast.

This article is for general information and does not replace individual medical or dietary advice.

What people ask when you put it down

Is it supposed to be that pink? Yes. See the section above, decide where you sit, and say so cheerfully rather than apologetically.

What is the red thing? Radicchio, which is a chicory, and a relative of the endive. The leaf everyone claims not to like turns out to be the thing they go back for once it has been in a hot pan.

Can I keep the fat? Strain it into a jar and refrigerate it. Roast potatoes in it, start a soup with it, fry an egg in it. A single dinner yields enough for a fortnight of better cooking, and throwing it away is the actual waste.

Make it yours, and make it ahead

The barley is the make-ahead. Cook it up to three days in advance, hold it back from the vinegar and cheese, and loosen it with a splash of hot stock when you reheat. Toast the walnuts a week out and keep them airtight. The pomegranate can be seeded in the morning and sits happily in the fridge. The duck itself wants cooking to order, and the radicchio collapses if it waits.

For variations, swap the fennel for Szechuan pepper and five spice and finish with orange instead of pomegranate. Use blood orange segments in place of pomegranate in late winter when it is cheap and the pomegranate is not. Add a spoonful of pan juices and a knob of butter to the barley if you want it richer. Grill the radicchio over charcoal in summer, which is better than the pan does it. Make it for two by halving everything except the barley, which keeps for days anyway.

Leftovers keep airtight in the refrigerator for up to three days, the barley for four. Cool everything quickly and refrigerate within two hours. Cold duck sliced thin over the barley with extra vinegar and a handful of leaves is a better lunch than reheating gives you, because reheating is what turns a rosy slice grey.

Approximate Nutrition per Serving

Calories 620
Protein 39 g
Carbohydrates 49 g
Fibre 6 g
Fat 30 g
Saturated fat 7 g
Iron 6.5 mg
Sodium 720 mg

Estimated from Health Canada's Canadian Nutrient File. Values shift with the size of the breasts, how much fat you pour off and whether the cheese goes in.

Shop the Story

Product Why it earns its place Price
NOW Iron Complex, 100 tabs For the women whose bloodwork already told them, not for everyone $10.69
CANPREV Magnesium Bis-Glycinate 200 Gentle, 120 g The mineral the barley brings, on the nights there is no barley $20.29

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I cook duck breast from frozen?

No. Thaw it overnight in the refrigerator and pat it very dry. Ice crystals in the skin turn to steam in the pan, and steam is the one thing that guarantees the skin will not crisp. A frozen breast also cooks unevenly, leaving a cold centre under an overdone edge.

Where do I buy duck breast in Canada, and what should it cost?

Most full-size supermarkets carry it chilled or frozen near the specialty poultry, and butchers will order it. Expect roughly $12 to $20 a breast depending on size and province. Frozen is often half the price and loses nothing if it is thawed slowly.

My kitchen filled with smoke. What did I do wrong?

The heat was too high or the fat stayed in the pan. Duck renders a remarkable amount, and once it is deeper than a few millimetres it starts to smoke. Pour it off two or three times during the eight minutes and keep the burner at medium-low.

Can I do this in the oven instead?

Partly. Render the skin in the pan as described, because an oven will not do that part, then finish the breasts at 200°C for four to six minutes if yours are unusually thick. Starting in an oven gives you a soft skin no amount of later searing recovers.

What should I pour with it?

A medium-bodied red with acid rather than tannin. Barbera, Valpolicella or a cool-climate Pinot Noir all work, and so does a dry cider. For a non-alcoholic pour, try unsweetened pomegranate juice cut half and half with sparkling water.

More from the Viva kitchen

Sources