In the 1980s, a major flood left Bangladesh's turmeric harvest damp and dull. Shoppers wanted the bright yellow they were used to. Some processors found a cheap fix in lead chromate, the pigment in yellow industrial paint. Stanford researchers traced the practice in 2019 and linked it to raised lead levels in the people eating the curry.

Your own spice drawer is almost certainly not that drawer. The story still shows where the risk in a jar of spice usually enters: after the harvest, during grinding, colouring and storage. The organic leaf on the label speaks mostly to the field.

So buy organic for what it promises, and choose the brand for what it leaves out. Sorting your drawer that way takes one Sunday evening and a garbage bag.

What the organic logo on a spice jar covers in Canada
The worry Organic covers it?
Synthetic pesticides on the farm Yes
Irradiation after harvest Yes, banned outright
Chemical fumigation in shipping Yes, for the common fumigants
Heavy metals in the powder No, nobody tests for them

Are organic spices lead-free?

Consumer Reports put the question to a lab in 2021. Its testers bought 126 herbs and spices from 38 brands, from store labels to national names. About a third carried enough arsenic, lead and cadmium to worry about with regular use.

Organic jars were not reliably cleaner. Price didn't predict the results either. Metals arrive from the soil the plant grew in, or from the mills and polishers that handle it later. Certification checks how the plant was raised. Nobody at the certifier runs the finished powder through a lab.

The part organic gets right

Canada's organic standard bans ionizing radiation at any point in the supply chain. A jar that has been irradiated loses its organic status. The chemical fumigants most often used on stored crops are off the permitted list too.

For a powder you stir into breakfast every day, those are good reasons to pay a little more. Rootalive Organic Turmeric Powder is a single ingredient and certified organic, and the 200 gram bag costs about what a fancy latte does.

Is there lead in cinnamon?

In September 2024, Consumer Reports tested 36 ground cinnamons and cinnamon blends. Twelve reached one part per million of lead, the level at which it told readers to throw the jar out. Most of the high readings came from discount shops. The familiar supermarket names tested low.

The jar worth keeping for your oats is Ceylon, the pale, papery quills grown mostly in Sri Lanka. Rootalive Organic Ceylon Cinnamon Powder has a soft, almost floral sweetness that makes everyday cassia taste like a scented candle.

Sunday night, the drawer

Pull every jar out and line them up on the counter. Anything ground, unlabelled, bought from a bulk bin or priced suspiciously low goes first. Turmeric that glows like a highlighter pen deserves a second look, because the real root dries to a warmer orange.

Then email the brands you plan to keep. Ask whether they test each batch for heavy metals, and whether they will share the lab certificate. A company that replies within a day has usually been asked before.

Put back only the jars that came with an answer.

Frequently asked questions

Which spices had the most heavy metals in testing?

In Consumer Reports' 2021 tests, every thyme and oregano sample was flagged as a concern. Seven of the 15 spice types tested had every brand below the level of concern, so the problem sat in particular spices and suppliers rather than across the whole shelf.

Is Ceylon cinnamon healthier than cassia?

They are different species. Cassia, the common supermarket kind, contains far more coumarin, a natural compound that can strain the liver when eaten in large daily amounts. Ceylon contains only traces. For anyone who takes cinnamon every day, that difference matters more than the organic label.

Does Canada test spices for lead?

Yes. Health Canada and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency run surveillance programs for chemical contaminants in food, including lead, and the CFIA issues recalls when it finds unsafe levels. Internationally, the Codex Alimentarius food standards body has proposed 2.5 parts per million as a lead limit for bark spices such as cinnamon.

This article is for general information and does not replace medical advice. If you are worried about lead exposure, ask your doctor about a blood test.

Shop the story

Read next

Sources