"Third one this month," Priya says, holding up a thumbnail split down the middle by a can of lime seltzer.
It's three o'clock in the office kitchen, and your desk-mate has a theory. Her biotin gummies stopped working, so she has ordered silica, the mineral every nail forum now swears by. She wants to know if she picked the right one.
Fair question. The small print on the label decides how much of it reaches her. In one London test, the best-absorbed silicon came from a supplement and from a glass of alcohol-free beer. The worst came from colloidal silica, sold in many gels, which delivered almost nothing. Brittle nails trouble up to one person in five, mostly women. Plenty of people are standing where Priya is.
The short answer: Silica may help brittle nails a little, though the proof is thin. Choose a type your body absorbs well and give it months, not weeks. Meanwhile, protect the nail you already have. That part works on its own.
Does silica help brittle nails?
Yes, a little, and the proof rests on one study. In Belgium in 2005, researchers gave 50 women with sun-damaged skin either a silicon supplement or a dummy pill every day for 20 weeks. Neither the women nor the team knew who was taking which.
The study was mainly about skin, and the machines measured that. Nails were an extra. Each woman scored her own nail and hair brittleness on a simple scale, and the silicon group's scores dropped from where they started. The summary measures that drop against the women's own starting point. It gives no comparison with the dummy pill, which is the test that would settle it.
So the honest grade is promising. Nobody has repeated the nail result with a ruler, a larger group or another type of silicon. Twenty weeks is also a clue about patience. A fingernail grows out slowly, over months.
| The claim | Where the evidence stands |
|---|---|
| Silica for brittle nails | One small trial, self-rated. EMERGING |
| Biotin for brittle nails | Small studies, few comparison groups. EMERGING |
| The form changes absorption | Measured head to head. ESTABLISHED |
| Short nails, gloves and moisturiser | Standard specialist advice. ESTABLISHED |
The beer in the London lab
At St Thomas' Hospital in London, a team from King's College set out to answer Priya's question in 2009. Healthy volunteers arrived fasting, swallowed one source of silicon, and handed over blood and urine for the hours that followed. A week later, they came back and tried another.
The sources were wonderfully mixed: bananas, green beans, a mineral antacid, three supplements and alcohol-free beer. The urine showed how much each one delivered. The winners were a supplement called MMST and the beer, each passing about two thirds of its silicon into the body.
Green beans did well too. Bananas, often listed as a top source, gave up almost none of theirs, so the one in your desk drawer is mostly a banana. Colloidal silica came last, with about one per cent absorbed.
A third option, ch-OSA, landed in the middle, at roughly one sixth. The Belgian volunteers took ch-OSA. So the only nail result belongs to the middle performer, and the star of the London test has never had a nail trial of its own.

Reading the bottle in the drugstore aisle
Turn the bottle around and find the type, written in brackets after the word silicon. Then look for an eight-digit NPN, which means Health Canada has licensed the product as a natural health product.
If you want what the trial used, look for ch-OSA in those brackets. The Belgian women took 10 mg of silicon a day. Skip gels labelled colloidal silica, the form that came last in London.
If you would rather have the best absorber, CanPrev Silicon Beauty uses MMST from Nova Scotian quartz. One capsule a day helps maintain healthy hair, skin and nails. Read the label twice, though. Each capsule also carries biotin.
So Priya's gummies are back in the story. Biotin can scramble some routine blood tests, which we covered in our piece on biotin and lab results. Whichever bottle you buy, tell your doctor what you take before any bloodwork.
Is silica better than biotin for nails?
No one knows, because no one has tested them against each other. Biotin's evidence comes from a handful of small studies, few with a comparison group. A 2017 review from Weill Cornell Medicine in New York called the results promising and asked for larger, controlled trials.
Silica sits in much the same place, with one controlled trial that only measured nails as a side question. Switching from one to the other is a reasonable experiment, as long as you treat it like one. Change one thing, take a photo of your nails on day one and judge it next season.
Collagen has a nail study too. Our collagen investigation explains why its trials deserve a second look before a third tub joins the shelf.
Put the can opener down
A healthy nail is built like a stack of paper, about 25 layers of flattened cells packed tight. Fats make up about five per cent of it and help hold the layers together. An international panel of nail specialists, writing in 2019, noted that one of those fats declines with age, especially after menopause. Women's nails also start with weaker bonds between the cells.
Splitting usually begins where those layers end, at the free edge. Every lever action, scrape and pry works the sheets apart, the way a thumb riffles a paperback. A pull tab is a small lever pressed against the most fragile edge of the nail, several times a day.
The free fixes come first. Open cans with a spoon handle or a key. Keep nails short. A long edge catches on things and dries out faster. Wear heavy cotton gloves for gardening, moving boxes and anything else rough on the hands.
Then put some fat back. The same panel recommends nail moisturisers with rich, sealing ingredients, rubbed into the nail and cuticle. Make it a bedtime habit, when nothing will wipe it straight off.
The hand cream already on your nightstand will do, as long as it is thick. Butters such as shea or cacao and oils such as castor seal better than a light lotion. Press a small dab into each nail and cuticle, and leave it on overnight.
The free part starts working on the nail you have today. A supplement, if it helps at all, works on the nail that hasn't grown in yet.
Priya has taped a teaspoon to the office fridge. Her silica arrives Thursday, and she has a photo of her thumbnail dated for April.
Shop the Story
Frequently asked questions
How long does silica take to work on nails?
Plan on four to six months. Fingernails grow about 3.5 mm a month in healthy adults, so a new nail takes most of half a year to reach the tip. Any change starts at the base and moves outward. Judge it by comparing dated photos, not by how the tips feel after a few weeks.
Can brittle nails be a sign of a health problem?
Sometimes. Thyroid problems, low iron, psoriasis, eczema and fungal infections can all make nails split or crumble. Nail specialists note that most people with an underactive thyroid have nail changes. See a doctor if your nails change colour or shape, thicken, lift or turn brittle suddenly, especially all at once.
Is it safe to take silica and biotin together?
Many nail supplements combine them, so check what you already take before adding a second bottle. Stick to the label dose. Tell your doctor or pharmacist about both before any blood test, and ask first if you are pregnant, breastfeeding or take prescription medication.
Do nail hardeners and strengthening polishes work?
They can make brittle nails look and feel better while you wear them, and some contain silicon. Specialists say more research is needed to prove lasting benefits. Acrylic and sculpted nails can protect a split edge, but the products and removal can make fragile nails worse.
This article is for general information and does not replace medical advice. See a doctor or pharmacist about nails that change suddenly, and before starting a supplement if you are pregnant, breastfeeding or take medication.
Sources
- Barel A, Calomme M, Timchenko A, et al. Effect of oral intake of choline-stabilized orthosilicic acid on skin, nails and hair in women with photodamaged skin. Archives of Dermatological Research, 2005;297(4):147-53.
- Sripanyakorn S, Jugdaohsingh R, Dissayabutr W, et al. The comparative absorption of silicon from different foods and food supplements. British Journal of Nutrition, 2009;102(6):825-34.
- Chessa MA, Iorizzo M, Richert B, et al. Pathogenesis, clinical signs and treatment recommendations in brittle nails: a review. Dermatology and Therapy, 2020;10(1):15-27.
- Lipner SR, Scher RK. Biotin for the treatment of nail disease: what is the evidence? Journal of Dermatological Treatment, 2018;29(4):411-414.
- Yaemsiri S, Hou N, Slining MM, He K. Growth rate of human fingernails and toenails in healthy American young adults. Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology, 2010;24(4):420-3.
- Health Canada. Licensed Natural Health Products Database.